Posted in

Do check valves need a strainer?

As a check valve supplier who’s spent thousands of hours on the phone with plant managers, piping designers, and maintenance crews, I get asked the same question at least twice a week: “Do check valves really need a strainer?” It’s not a trivial question—skip the answer, and you’re staring down clogs, pressure drops, or even a failed check valve in the middle of a process shutdown that costs tens of thousands of dollars in downtime. Let’s break this down like I would in a workshop, no jargon that doesn’t make sense, just the real-world stuff we see every day. Check Valves

First, let’s start with the basics: what’s a check valve, and what does a strainer do? A check valve’s whole job is non-negotiable—let fluid flow one way, and stop it from going backward. That’s it. They’re the silent workhorses in everything from water treatment lines to oil refineries, HVAC systems to municipal wastewater plants. Without them, you’d get water hammer, which can crack pipes, damage pumps, or even cause serious structural issues. Now a strainer? That’s a simple device, usually a perforated metal basket or mesh screen, installed upstream of equipment like check valves. Its only job is to catch the physical gunk in fluid: sediment, pipe scale, welding slag, small debris that gets left in piping during installation or washes in from raw sources like rivers or well water.

Here’s where the confusion starts. Some people will tell you “all check valves need a strainer,” and others will say “they’re totally unnecessary.” The truth is, it depends on three big factors: what’s flowing through your line, what type of check valve you’re using, and how much maintenance you’re willing to do. Let’s go through each one, because that’s where most people miss the nuance.

First, fluid type. If you’re moving clean, processed water in a closed loop HVAC system, or pure chemicals in a sealed manufacturing line, there’s almost no debris. No strainer needed—you can go decades without a clog. But if you’re dealing with raw sewage, well water that has lots of sand and silt, or slurry lines with tiny solid particles, a strainer is non-negotiable. Last year, I worked with a municipal wastewater plant in Ohio that installed a swing check valve on their raw influent line without a strainer. Six months later, the valve’s flapper was jammed shut by a chunk of pipe scale that had washed in during a line repair. They had to drain a 20-foot section of pipe, pull the valve, and replace the flapper—costing them $12,000 in labor and downtime. They added a basket strainer upstream after that, and haven’t had a similar issue since. That’s the kind of story we live with as suppliers—we don’t just sell valves, we see the mess when people skip the basics.

Next, check valve type. Not all check valves are built the same, and that changes the strainer question entirely. Swing check valves, for example, have a flapper that swings open and closed. Debris can get caught between the flapper and the seat, preventing a tight seal, or wedge under the flapper so it can’t fully close—leading to backflow and water hammer. A lift check valve, which uses a disc that moves up and down, is even more sensitive. Small debris can jam the disc halfway, so it doesn’t open fully, causing a big pressure drop. We’ve had customers with lift check valves in small diameter lines (2-inch to 6-inch) that started seeing 20% higher pressure drop after just three months—because debris was clogging the disc’s guide. That’s a silent problem; you don’t notice it until your pump starts working overtime, and by then, you’re wasting energy. On the flip side, ball check valves and spring-loaded check valves are a bit more robust. The ball or spring tends to push small debris through instead of trapping it, so in clean lines, they can go without a strainer. But even then, if you’re in a line where debris is a possibility, adding a strainer still adds 10 years to the valve’s lifespan.

Then there’s the maintenance angle. I’ve got a customer in a food processing plant that has 12 swing check valves on their raw milk lines. They never added strainers, but their team does a full inspection and flush of every valve every 45 days. They catch small debris before it causes damage, and they’re okay with that routine because they’ve got the labor. But another customer—a steel mill—has 80 check valves on their cooling water lines. They can’t shut down a line for inspection every month; that would cost too much in production. For them, a strainer is non-negotiable. It lets them go 18 to 24 months between valve checks, which is critical for operations that run 24/7.

Wait, but what about when strainers cause their own problems? It’s not all one-sided. We’ve heard from customers who have strainers clog so often that they have to take a line down every week to clean the screen. That’s a real issue, especially in lines with very high debris content. In those cases, a bigger mesh strainer, or a self-cleaning strainer, might be the answer instead of skipping the strainer entirely. Or, if you’re dealing with extremely fine debris (like sand less than 1mm), a strainer with a smaller mesh might be necessary. That’s where our team comes in—we don’t just sell check valves or strainers; we help customers size and select the right combo for their line.

Let’s talk about what the standards say, because that’s a big part of the answer. Most piping codes—API 6D for valves, ASME B31 for piping, even the International Plumbing Code—don’t say check valves must have a strainer. But they do say that any equipment with moving parts that could be damaged by debris should have protection. That’s the fine print. So it’s not a requirement, it’s a risk assessment. If your line carries debris, the risk of a failed check valve is too high to ignore the strainer. If it’s clean, you can get away without it, but we still recommend it as a proactive measure.

Here’s a common misconception people have: strainers add pressure drop, so they’re bad for flow. It’s true, a strainer can add a little pressure drop—usually 1 to 3 psi, depending on the size and mesh. For most lines, that’s negligible. But if you’re working with a low-pressure line, like a small domestic water line, you have to account for that. Our team helps customers calculate the total pressure drop so they don’t end up with a line that’s too weak to work. That’s part of our service—we don’t just hand over a product; we walk through the whole system with you.

I want to share a recent example that sums this up perfectly. A customer contacted us last month, saying their check valves were failing every 8 to 10 months. They had swing check valves on their well water lines, no strainers. We recommended adding a 10-mesh basket strainer upstream, and switching to a slightly more robust check valve with a thicker flapper. They did that, and in the six months since, they haven’t had a single failure. The strainer catches the sand and sediment from the well, which was the main cause of the flapper wear. They saved more than enough in valve replacement costs in the first six months to cover the cost of the strainer and the valve upgrade. That’s the ROI no one talks about—proactive protection that pays for itself quickly.

Now, when is a strainer not a good idea? If you’re in a line with extremely high debris that would clog a strainer faster than a check valve, for one. Or if you have a very small line (under 1 inch) where a strainer would cause too much pressure drop, or where you can inspect the check valve very easily. But those cases are rare. For 90% of the lines we work with, adding a strainer to a check valve is a no-brainer.

Let’s also address the long-term lifespan. A check valve without a strainer—especially in a debris-heavy line—will wear out 2 to 3 times faster than one with a strainer. Debris causes abrasion on the seat and moving parts, leading to leaks, backflow, and eventually total failure. I’ve seen check valves that were only 2 years old because of unmanaged debris, while check valves with a strainer can last 15, 20, even 25 years. That’s a huge difference in total cost of ownership.

As a supplier, we don’t push strainers on every customer just to make extra sales. We’ve had customers come to us saying they skipped the strainer and had a valve fail, and now they want a solution. We work with them to figure out the right setup. If a customer has a clean line, we’ll tell them they don’t need a strainer, but we’ll also tell them why adding one is worth the small upfront cost to avoid big problems later. That’s how we do business—we build long-term relationships, not one-off sales.

So to circle back to the original question: Do check valves need a strainer? The short answer is, not always, but in most cases, yes. It’s not a universal rule, it’s a case-by-case decision based on your fluid, your check valve type, your maintenance schedule, and your operational needs.

If you’re not sure whether your check valve needs a strainer, or if you’re tired of dealing with frequent valve failures, our team is here to help. We’ll walk through your specific line, assess the risks, and recommend the right combination of check valve and strainer that fits your budget and needs. Don’t wait for a shutdown to figure this out—reach out to our team today to discuss your project.

Special Alloy Strainer References

  1. API Standard 6D, Specification for Pipeline Valves, American Petroleum Institute
  2. ASME B31.3, Process Piping, American Society of Mechanical Engineers
  3. International Plumbing Code (IPC), International Code Council
  4. Miller, J. (2022). Pump and Valve System Reliability: Minimizing Downtime and Repair Costs. Industrial Press.
  5. Barnes, R. (2021). “Strainer Selection for Industrial Piping Systems,” Journal of Pipeline Engineering, Vol. 20, No. 3, pp. 1–12.
  6. National Water Supply Improvement Association (NWSA) Best Practices for Water Pipeline Components, 2020.

NSV Valve Corporation
NSV Valve Corporation is one of the most professional check valves manufacturers and suppliers in China, featured by quality products and good service. Please rest assured to buy check valves made in China here from our factory.
Address: Puyi Road,Sanqiao Industrial Zone, Oubei Street, Yongjia County,Zhejiang,China
E-mail: info@nsvvalve.com
WebSite: https://www.nsvvalves.com/